Akelos Framework v1 forum archive. This forum is no longer maintained. To report bugs please visit https://github.com/akelos/akelos/issues
    • CommentAuthorRaquel
     
    I'm really not trying to start trouble. I've been looking for a framework to use in developing a couple of large applications. I've looked at Code Ignitor and Cake but have really been fascinated with Akelos and Symfony. I like Symfony because of the copious documentation and the number of available plugins and things like code snippets. I like Akelos because it supports PHP4 and PHP5. I have machines running 4 and some running 5. Everything I've read in the last 3 or 4 days indicates that the two are pretty equal, except for those things I mentioned. Is there something I'm missing? What might make Akelos a better choice than Symfony?
    • CommentAuthorJeff
     

    Hey,

    Symfony also has an automatic admin interface while Akelos has Sintags (rails-styled template code). The main reason I'm using Akelos is that it supports php4 also. The Sintags provides a much readable template without much overhead due to Akelos' caching. Depending on what you want/expect your large applications you're designing to have. Highly-critical, looming deadlines, or broad-range of feature requirements aren't ideal if you want to use Akelos since it lacks large documentation and the vast feature-set of Symfony.

    Akelos is more of a rails-inspired framework and Symfony tries to be a hybrid of a variety of frameworks. Symfony's schema.xml seems a bit annoying, although I think it's possible to generate it via an existing database. I'll admit I haven't really checked out symfony enough, but I'm using a php4 enviroment, so I didn't really have incentives to.

    CodeIgniter is good for people new to the entire MVC / framework environment as opposed to flat php files. The only problem is that there's few automation done for you. CakePHP is has more automation, but you have to hack around to implement features that cakephp doesn't already provide, like custom validation.

    I chose Akelos, besides the php4 issue, is that I prefer the rails-styled syntax. I learned the basics of RoR and since my personal projects aren't critical or deadline driven, I'm willing to spend time learning the in's and out's of the framework.

    Just my two cents. :)

    • CommentAuthorraslam
     
    Hi,

    I am using symfony for my project. The only reason i'm using akelos is its support for php4.
    I like symfony over akelos becuase of its vast configurability and more over its great documentation. I took less time learning symfony than akelos.

    Recently it has been posted on symfony forums that yahoo's new Bookmarks now use symfony framework. Yahoo techincal support has confirmed it and they have agreed to contribute there modifications/plugins to symfony community.

    But I can say akelos is a pretty good framework and Bermi has done a great job. Whoever uses akelos should contribute and encourage its core developers.

    --
    raslam